Morningstar’s First Global Study of Investor Returns Evaluates Impact of Investor Behaviour and Finds Automatic Savings Plans Produce Better Outcomes

Sydney - 8 June 2017

Morningstar, Inc., a leading provider of independent investment research, today published its first global study of investor returns, “Mind the Gap 2017,” which measures how the average investor fared in a fund and the impact investor behavior can have on investment outcomes. The study uses the Morningstar Investor Returns methodology to derive a dollar-weighted return of a fund that incorporates the effect of cash inflows and outflows from purchases and sales, as well as the increase in a fund’s assets. The “gap” refers to the shortfall between funds’ money-weighted and time-weighted returns, reflecting how opportunely investors have timed their investments.

During the five-year period through Dec. 31, 2016, the study found that investor returns across the globe varied from stated returns, on average, by a range of -1.40 percent to 0.53 percent per year. However, investors achieved better outcomes when using systematic investment programs and invested in lower-cost funds. The study draws on preliminary Morningstar open-end mutual fund data from Australia, Canada, Hong Kong, Luxembourg, Singapore, South Korea, Taiwan, the United Kingdom, and the United States and calculates average asset-weighted investor returns and average total fund returns. Morningstar also tested four factors and their effect on investor returns: expense ratio, risk, standard deviation, and manager tenure.

“Steady investment contributions to savings plans and automatic rebalancing proved to be key in generating positive investor returns in countries including Australia, South Korea, and the United States,” said Russel Kinnel, chair of Morningstar’s North America ratings committee and editor of Morningstar® FundInvestorâ„ . “As savings plans increasingly offer an automatic investment option, investors are also getting more access to lower-cost funds. Our research demonstrates that, when sorted on fees, lower-cost funds produced better investor returns across the board, a trend surfacing in Luxembourg and the United States.”

Key highlights of the study include:

  • Investors in Singapore experienced the largest negative investor return gap, at -1.40 percent per year for the five years ended December 2016. By contrast, investors in Australian superannuation funds benefited from the largest positive investor return gap at 0.53 percent per year.
  • Investor returns per year proved positive for allocation funds in the United States at 0.05 percent, superannuation funds in Australia at 0.53 percent, and fixed-income funds in South Korea at 0.47 percent. These countries all offer investment vehicles with automatic contribution or payment options that keep investors on track and prevent them from unwise market timing moves.
  • The investor return gap in the United States shrunk to 37 basis points annualized over 10 years from 54 basis points for the 10 years ended 2016, indicating that investors are making less harmful market timing calls.
  • In the UK, diversified-equity fund investors produced better results on average than allocation fund investors with a -0.27 percent and -0.55 percent investor return gap, respectively.
  • When grouped by expense ratio, investor returns declined as funds rose in cost, often by more than the difference in cost.

Morningstar’s manager research team will release an in-depth investor returns study for Australia in 2017.

Morningstar has approximately 130 manager research analysts worldwide who cover approximately 4,270 funds. The company provides data on approximately 217,000 open-end mutual funds, 11,600 closed-end funds, and 14,100 exchange-traded product listings as of March 31, 2017.

Become a bobsguide member to access the following

1. Unrestricted access to bobsguide
2. Send a proposal request
3. Insights delivered daily to your inbox
4. Career development